The Ontario Court of Appeal has held that a $300 million policy limit does not override a clear $10 million sublimit for code upgrades.
The Thunder Bay Flood Claim and the $10 Million Code Upgrade Sublimit
In Thunder Bay (City) v. Ontario Municipal Insurance Exchange, a heavy rainstorm in 2012 flooded Thunder Bay’s wastewater pollution control plant. Raw sewage entered tunnels and affected several buildings.
The plant was originally built in 1964 and had undergone several expansions. By the time of the flood, parts of the facility no longer complied with current building codes and bylaws. Repairing the flood damage involved upgrading the plant.
OMEX acknowledged coverage for the loss. The dispute concerned how much coverage was available for the upgrades.
The policy had a general limit of $300 million for any one loss and a $10 million sublimit for Demolition and Increased Cost of Construction (DICC). OMEX maintained that the code-upgrade costs were subject to that sublimit.
The City disagreed. It argued that the replacement cost provisions covered those costs independently and that the DICC clause extended coverage beyond what was already available. The motion judge rejected that interpretation. The Court of Appeal agreed.
Why Replacement Cost Coverage Did Not Override the Sublimit
The City’s argument had a textual footing. The policy’s Basis of Loss Settlement clause expressly addressed situations where a law or bylaw restricted repairs using materials of like kind and quality. In those circumstances, the City argued that settlement would include the increased costs necessary to meet the minimum legal requirements.
The DICC clause also addressed code compliance, including increased repair or reconstruction costs involving damaged and undamaged facilities.
The City argued that the DICC sublimit applied to the additional coverage provided by that clause, leaving the replacement cost coverage available under the general policy limit.
The Court of Appeal disagreed, finding that the insuring agreement expressly made coverage subject to the policy’s conditions and limitations. The declarations identified the DICC sublimit, and the DICC wording addressed losses that triggered enforcement of laws governing construction or repair.
Although the DICC clause expanded slightly on the Basis of Loss Settlement clause, that did not support the City’s proposed interpretation. The Court concluded that allowing the replacement cost provisions to bypass the cap would render the sublimit meaningless.
The Court also addressed betterment, noting that replacement cost coverage already includes an element of betterment because it covers depreciation. The Court confirmed that an insurer can expressly limit what it pays for betterment, including code upgrades to older buildings.
The City also relied on premiums calculated using the plant’s full replacement cost. But the Court found the policy clear and unambiguous. There was therefore no need to resort to interpretive principles or other evidence of intention applicable where ambiguity exists.
The appeal was dismissed.
What Thunder Bay v. OMEX Means for Property Insurers and Adjusters
For property claims, the decision reinforces the need to read the replacement cost provisions, coverage clauses, and sublimit schedule together.
An express promise to pay increased costs caused by building laws does not complete the analysis. The next question is whether another provision limits that payment.
Adjusters should also identify which claimed costs relate to ordinary repairs and which arise from code compliance. Where damaged and undamaged portions of a facility are involved, the wording governing each category matters.
Thunder Bay turned on the policy before the Court. Its practical lesson is straightforward: a replacement cost clause can provide coverage for an expense while a specific sublimit determines how much the insurer must pay.
See Thunder Bay (City) v. Ontario Municipal Insurance Exchange, 2026 ONCA 827 (CanLII)


